Running an independent insurance agency requires adaptability. New regulations, carrier requirements, and consumer expectations keep you on your toes. Whether you are rolling out a new AMS or redefining your onboarding process, change is inevitable. But most implementation projects don’t fail because of technology; they fail because of avoidable implementation mistakes.

If you've ever watched a shiny new system with so much potential collect dust while your team resorts to their trusty spreadsheets, you're certainly not alone.

Let's explore five of the most common pitfalls and how to avoid them.

‍

Technology Before Process: Don't Make a Mess Faster

Picture this: You implement a CRM system due to infrequent client follow-up. Half a year down the line, your staff is still spending most of their time entering data, and client communication is still more fragmented than before. What went wrong? You automated an imperfect process.

Before you buy new software, map out your existing processes. How do leads move through your agency? How do you handle when customers call in with claims? Are renewal procedures the same for every team member?

Solve these issues by hand first. Create formal procedures, identify handoff points, and eliminate redundancy. Add technology later to support these streamlined processes. That way, automation makes it more efficient, not chaotic.

‍

Perfectionism Paralysis: Start Where You'll Be Successful

Insurance professionals are often risk-averse by nature, and this reserve can come back to haunt them during implementations. Most agencies fall into a cycle of infinite planning, attempting to guess every potential issue before they make the move.

"Suppose the integration with the carrier portal doesn't go as planned."

"Suppose the mobile app confuses older customers."

While these are valid worries, waiting for perfection is the same as waiting perpetually. Instead, start with your most impactful areas. If client onboarding is your biggest pain point, tackle that first. Achieve quick wins that create momentum and confidence.

Your commercial lines might be complex, but personal lines could be simplified all at once.

Pick your fights, start where you'll see the most improvement, and build from there.

‍

Underestimating Change Management: Invest in Your People

Your toughest challenge to implementation isn't technical, it's human. Your producers have sold the same way for years. Your staff has muscle memory for current practices. Even when new systems promise easier workflows, people push back.

This is where most agencies fall short. They spend 80% of their effort on selecting and implementing systems and just 20% on helping people adapt. Turn this ratio around.

Start describing early on why changes are happening and how they will be of benefit to individual team members. Will the new system reduce data entry time? Make client data more accessible? Get your team involved in the implementation process. Have experienced producers test out new systems and provide feedback. When people help design the change, they are more invested in how it turns out.

Plan to intensively train, but don't stop there. Check in regularly after go-live, create reference guides, and give yourself a chance to acclimate to the learning curve.

‍

Measuring Too Much Instead of What Counts:

Your systems today can report on everything: quote generation time, policies by producer, client retention by type of coverage, average premiums, and dozens more. The temptation is to monitor it all. But if you're tracking everything, nothing gets the attention it deserves. Your producers are swamped with reports, useful trends get buried in noise, and decision-making is harder.

Streamline to metrics that are most related to your agency's goals. If growth is highest on the agenda, track new client acquisition and average client value. If retention is most important, track renewal rates and customer feedback.

For each role, identify three to five key measures. Producers might track new business written, closing ratio, and referrals. Your service team might track response time and retention rates.

Keep it simple. Create habits and data-driven conversations, and then enhance sophistication later.

‍

Lack of Executive Commitment: Lead by Example

If you’re a leader in an agency, your employees watch everything that you do.

If you approve a CRM but keep on using your current spreadsheets, what message does that send? If you need training but don't go to sessions yourself, how important can they be?

Executive commitment means more than signing checks and approving timelines. It means actively using new systems, going to training, telling success stories, and holding everyone, including yourself, accountable.

When your employees see you learning the new CRM together with them and even using it for your own clients, they know the transformation is real. When you mention statistics from the new system during meetings, you reinforce its value.

This is particularly true in smaller independent shops where your leadership style has a direct influence on daily activities. Your commitment will permeate every aspect of the implementation.

‍

Making It Work for Your Agency

These mistakes pop up in agencies around the country, regardless of size or sophistication. The silver lining? They're all wholly avoidable.

Prioritize process refinement before adding technology. Choose incremental progress over idealized methods. Invest heavily in bringing your people along. Choose important metrics in preference to full dashboards. And lead by example in everything you do.

Implementation will always be challenging, but with clear strategies and committed leadership, it is an effective vehicle for making a more efficient, profitable, and competitive agency.